Amelia Island Real Estate Search

Oyster Bay Harbour

"Oyster Bay is a low country style community that is unique in our area and is just minutes from Amelia Island. Beyond the southern character to many of the homes the gated community also has its own marina and yacht club. The community offers a community pool and tennis as well as optional membership in the club which includes a restaurant, bar, fitness center, marina, additional pool and many social activities. The club has scenic views across the St. Mary's River to Georgia. Many of the homes in the neighborhood look across the Intracoastal Waterway to downtown Fernandina Beach. 

 Last year in 2025 there were 13 total home sales. Sale prices ranged from $1,531,000 to $826,000. For comparison, there were 10 home sales in 2024 with a high sale price of $2,200,000. " - Gary Farnsworth

Search or follow the entire Amelia Island MLS here.

Oyster Bay Homes & Lots For Sale

96133 Oyster Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach
$1,175,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 116993 MLS
Your ultimate coastal retreat awaits in the premier gated community of Oyster Bay Harbour in Fernandina Beach along the St Mary’s river. Enter the home through a mahogany door to a one-of-a-kind custom home where you are welcomed to a light-filled home, characterized by soaring 12-foot ceilings with crown molding, hardwood hickory floors, and an expansive great room with gas fireplace. The gourmet kitchen was built with ample cabinetry and oversized quartz island. This home was designed for everyday living as well as effortless entertainment, inclusive of built in cabinetry and wet bar. The home offers three en-suite bedrooms with ample closet space for ultimate comfort. Two suites reside on the main level, including a luxurious primary retreat complete with bay window seating and an oversized walk-in shower. Upstairs, the flexible third suite easily adapts as a guest sanctuary, office, media room, or secondary living space. A sliding glass wall opens to a spacious screened-in tiled lanai and paved patio overlooking a serene lagoon. Fenced in yard provides ample space for a future pool, outdoor kitchen, or private garden oasis. Within Oyster Bay Harbour residents enjoy pickleball, clay tennis courts, RV and boat storage, and community pool. With an acceptable offer, the Seller will include a paid equity membership to Oyster Bay Yacht Club, unlocking deep-water access, private in-community boat docks, world-class dining, member events, and premier waterfront privileges.

96133 Oyster Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach
96014 Park Place, Fernandina Beach
$1,149,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 117610 MLS
OPEN HOUSE THIS SATURDAY, 10/24 FROM 12:30-2:30PM! Experience custom coastal luxury and gorgeous lakefront sunsets in this beautifully appointed 2018-built home in gated Oyster Bay Harbour! Thoughtfully designed for comfort and entertaining, this home features 10-foot ceilings, upgraded fixtures and finishes, plantation shutters, and abundant natural light. The main-floor primary suite offers two walk-in closets with Elfa shelving and a luxurious bath with soaking tub. A second main-floor bedroom and two upstairs bedrooms provide flexibility for guests and family. Additional spaces include a dedicated home office, formal dining room, breakfast nook and expanded lanai overlooking the lake. The gourmet kitchen impresses with Dolomite countertops, a 6-burner Dacor gas cooktop, double convection ovens, warming drawer, wine cooler, coffee station, custom soft-close cabinetry, and oversized walk-in pantry. Relax on the expansive screened lanai overlooking the peaceful lake, complete with connections for a future outdoor kitchen. Enjoy spectacular sunsets, fruit trees, and a low-maintenance backyard that can be fenced for your pups! Additional features include a Rinnai tankless water heater, buried propane tank, electric fireplace, security cameras, surround sound wiring, cedar closet, large walk-in attic storage, and generator hookup. The side-entry garage includes a dedicated golf cart bay. Enjoy Oyster Bay Harbour's pool, tennis, pickleball, playground, and boat/RV storage, plus optional Yacht Club membership with marina amenities. Just minutes from Amelia Island's beaches and historic downtown Fernandina Beach.

96014 Park Place, Fernandina Beach
96058 Bay View Drive, Fernandina Beach
$774,900
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 117483 MLS
Discover refined coastal living in the gated community of Oyster Bay. This updated four-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath residence pairs elegant finishes with a versatile layout, a private backyard, and a three-car garage—all just minutes from Amelia Island. Plantation shutters and updated flooring lend timeless style throughout, with commercial-grade luxury vinyl plank downstairs, luxury vinyl plank in the upstairs bedrooms, and engineered hardwood along the upstairs walkway. The renovated kitchen features granite countertops, new cabinetry, a stylish backsplash, stainless steel appliances, and gas cooking—an inviting setting for meals and entertaining. A dedicated office offers flexibility for working from home. Located on the main level, the primary suite provides a relaxing retreat with dual vanities, a jetted tub, and a renovated shower enclosed in frameless glass. Upstairs bedrooms and a Jack-and-Jill bathroom offer comfortable accommodations, while renovated showers and an updated powder room enhance the home’s polished appeal. Enjoy quiet mornings and relaxed evenings on the screened lanai overlooking the private backyard, where a grapefruit tree adds a charming Florida touch. Updated doors leading from the kitchen connect the interior with this outdoor retreat. Additional highlights include an exterior parking pad, a laundry utility sink, included washer and dryer, irrigation, gutters, and a water softener. A roof replaced in 2019 and HVAC systems updated in 2021 and 2022 further enhance the appeal. With its gated setting, extensive updates, and proximity to Amelia Island’s beaches, dining, and shopping, this Oyster Bay residence invites you to enjoy the coastal lifestyle.

96058 Bay View Drive, Fernandina Beach
96442 Soap Creek Drive, Fernandina Beach
$265,000
117551 MLS
MARSHFRONT SUNRISES & A VISION FOR YOUR CUSTOM COASTAL HOME! Discover a beautiful setting for your next chapter at 96442 Soap Creek Drive in the gated community of Oyster Bay Harbour. With east-facing views across the marsh, this homesite invites you to start the day with sunrise over the water and enjoy the changing colors, coastal birds, and natural rhythms of the marsh from your future home. Custom home plans designed specifically to maximize this lot’s marsh views are available for separate purchase—offering inspiration and a thoughtful starting point for bringing your coastal retreat to life. Imagine a light-filled home with inviting outdoor living spaces where morning coffee comes with an unforgettable view. Oyster Bay Harbour pairs peaceful, oak-lined streets with amenities that make it easy to enjoy life close to home. Residents have access to a community pool and clubhouse, pickleball and tennis courts, a playground, and boat/RV storage. Optional membership at Oyster Bay Yacht Club offers a deep-water marina, waterfront dining, fitness center, pool, and an active social calendar, all just a golf cart ride away. Enjoy the tranquility of this established coastal community with Amelia Island’s beaches and historic downtown Fernandina Beach approximately 15 minutes away, plus convenient access to Jacksonville International Airport and Kings Bay. Whether you envision a year-round residence or a coastal getaway, this marshfront homesite offers a beautiful backdrop for a home designed around the view.

96442 Soap Creek Drive, Fernandina Beach
96614 Bay View Drive, Fernandina Beach
$257,000
115055 MLS
iWelcome to waterfront living at its finest in highly desirable Oyster Bay Community! The double lot overlooks the intercoastal and offers access to a clubhouse and marina right at your doorstep. With many amenities including a clubhouse with optional membership, children's playground, clay tennis court, and RV storage, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Located just minutes from Historic downtown with its charming restaurants and shops, as well as beautiful beaches, this location truly offers the best of both worlds. Don't miss out on this incredible opportunity to build your dream waterfront home in this coveted community. Contact us today for more information!

96614 Bay View Drive, Fernandina Beach
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!