Oyster Bay Harbour

"Oyster Bay is a low country style community that is unique in our area and is just minutes from Amelia Island. Beyond the southern character to many of the homes the gated community also has its own marina and yacht club. The community offers a community pool and tennis as well as optional membership in the club which includes a restaurant, bar, fitness center, marina, additional pool and many social activities. The club has scenic views across the St. Marys River to Georgia. Many of the homes in the neighborhood look across the Intracoastal Waterway to downtown Fernandina Beach. New and existing resale homes are available. For 2021 we saw 26 homes sell with a high price of $1,287,000 and a low price of $555,000. For 2022 there were a total of 10 sales. Low price was $629,600 and the high sale was $1,329,700. In 2023 there were a total of 11 home sales ranging from $703,000 to $2,050,000." - Gary Farnsworth

Search or follow the entire Amelia Island MLS here.

Oyster Bay Homes & Lots For Sale

property image

$1,869,000

96321 BAY VIEW DRIVE, Fernandina Beach

This magnificent 5 bed/5.5 bath NEWLY RENOVATED home on an oversized lot in the exclusive Oyster Bay Harbour gated community offers picturesque west-facing marsh front vi...

  • Beds5
  • Baths6
  • MLS107156

property image

$1,300,000

96582 COMPASS POINT DRIVE, Fernandina Beach

Extraordinary new construction home in gated Oyster Bay Harbour with explosive views from nearly every room across marsh, yacht club, and historic downtown Fernandina Bea...

  • Beds4
  • Baths3
  • MLS106992

property image

$1,100,000

96630 BAY VIEW DRIVE, Fernandina Beach

New construction in Oyster Bay! This home is being built on a double lot with amazing views overlooking the marsh. The plan features 2600 sqft, 3 bedroom, 2 & 1/2 bath, 2...

  • Beds3
  • Baths3
  • MLS106359

property image

$1,050,000

96199 LIGHT WIND DRIVE, Fernandina Beach

This lakefront home defines low-country luxury in the sought-after Oyster Bay Harbour Community. The home's naturally lit, open floorplan offers 5 beds, 3.5 baths, Custom...

  • Beds5
  • Baths4
  • MLS106126

property image

$999,800

96026 PARK PLACE, Fernandina Beach

This lakefront home is a stunning example of low-country luxury in in the sought-after Oyster Bay Harbour Community. The home’s naturally lit floorplan offers 3 bedrooms,...

  • Beds3
  • Baths3
  • MLS105512

property image

$969,900

96058 BAY VIEW DRIVE, Fernandina Beach

Welcome to this grand two story home in the beautiful tree-lined community of Oyster Bay! Situated on one half acre, complete with an inviting circular drive and well man...

  • Beds4
  • Baths4
  • MLS106394

property image

$949,000

96594 COMPASS POINT DRIVE, Fernandina Beach

Amazing Marsh Views!! New construction in Oyster Bay Harbour! This gated community along the Amelia River includes a community pool, tennis courts, and is surrounded with...

  • Beds3
  • Baths3
  • MLS105857

property image

$899,000

96558 COMPASS POINT DRIVE, Fernandina Beach

New construction in Oyster Bay Harbour! This gated community along the Amelia River includes a community pool, tennis courts, and is surrounded with amazing marsh views. ...

  • Beds3
  • Baths3
  • MLS103512

property image

$719,000

96401 CONTESSA POINT DRIVE, Fernandina Beach

New construction in Oyster Bay Harbour! This gated community along the Amelia River includes a community pool, tennis courts, and is surrounded with amazing marsh views. ...

  • Beds3
  • Baths3
  • MLS101678

property image

$335,000

96524 SOAP CREEK DRIVE, Fernandina Beach

Build your custom home and indulge in the ultimate coastal living experience on this magnificent 1+ acre marsh-front homesite nestled within the sought-after community of...

  • MLS107049

property image

$299,900

96426 & 96430 CONCH COURT, Fernandina Beach

Build the home of your dreams on one of the few remaining marsh-front home sites in the sought-after Oyster Bay Harbour community. This vacant, double lot has South and E...

  • MLS104817

property image

$285,000

96600 SOAP CREEK DRIVE, Fernandina Beach

Come build the home of your dreams on one of the few remaining large marsh-front lots in the sought-after Oyster Bay Harbour community. This 1.06-acre lot has an East/Wes...

  • MLS106714

property image

$275,000

96614 BAY VIEW DRIVE, Fernandina Beach

STUNNING WATERFRONT VIEWS OF THE INTRACOASTAL! THESE LOTS, B-25 AND B-26 HAVE AN EAST/WEST ORIENTATION. A LITTLE MORE THAN A HALF ACRE TO BUILD YOUR DREAM HOME! Located i...

  • MLS105816

property image

$275,000

96424 SOAP CREEK DRIVE, Fernandina Beach

This large, marshfront lot in the sought-after Oyster Bay Harbour Community is the perfect place to build the home of your dreams! This nearly 1 acre lot has a South East...

  • MLS105506

property image

$235,000

96744 SOAP CREEK DRIVE, Fernandina Beach

Enjoy Direct Water Views across to Amelia Island from one of the most northern lots on Soap Creek Drive in the Waterway Oaks section of Oyster Bay Harbour. This 1.25-Acre...

  • MLS104358

Free Daily Email Updates

  • Automated home searches
  • Favorite properties
  • Email updates
  • And much more…

Amelia Island Plantation

Amelia Island Homes & Condos